2014 ENnie Award Follow-Up!

Last month I predicted the winners for this year’s ENnie awards – so now it’s time to seeAwards Image how I did!

The full list is below if you want to peruse it, but to sum up: if you have a product that isn’t based on fan-favorite brands Numenera/Monte Cook, Fate/Evil Hat, Pathfinder/Paizo, or Savage Worlds/Pinnacle, your chances are slim to none. By my count, there were 44 individual gold and silver awards, of which 40 had a chance to be won by products supporting one of these brands. They won 31 out of 40.

With that in mind, I’d like to see the ENnies introduce a “Best New Publisher Product” category (or something similar) that only includes products by brand new publishers instead of industry leaders, or some category with products that don’t rely on those leaders to support them. I’d also like to see the “Best Electronic Book” category better defined to explain how these books differ from other electronic books in other categories.

Okay, enough of that. On to the results!

Best Adventure (100%! I guessed both of these correctly.)

  • Trail of Cthulhu: Eternal Lies – Pelgrane Press (GOLD)
  • Razor Coast: Heart of the Razor – Frog God Games (SILVER)

Best Aid/Accessory (50%)

  • Numenera Creature Deck – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
  • Fate Dice – Eldritch Dice – Evil Hat Productions (SILVER)

I guessed the Silver correctly, but my Gold vote was for Odyssey: The Complete Game Master’s Guide to Campaign Management by Engine Publishing. I’d forgotten to take Monte Cook’s huge fan following into account, something you’ll see more of below.

Best Art, Interior (I should have realized that Pathfinder would take at least the Silver, considering Paizo and Pathfinder also have a huge fan following.)

  • Pathfinder Campaign Setting: Inner Sea Gods – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (SILVER)

My guesses were:
Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
Shadowrun 5th Edition Core Rulebook – Catalyst Game Labs (SILVER)

Best Art, Cover (I was a bit off on this one, since once again I forgot how the Paizo fanbase would perform.)

  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Mythic Adventures – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • Achtung! Cthulhu – Keeper’s Guide to the Secret War – Modiphius (SILVER)

My predictions were:
Shadowrun 5th Edition Core Rulebook – Catalyst Game Labs (GOLD)
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Mythic Adventures – Paizo Publishing (SILVER)

Best Blog (I got 50% here.)

  • Gnome Stew (GOLD)
  • AaWBlog (Adventureaweek.com) (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
Gnome Stew (GOLD)
Dorkland! (50% chance of SILVER)
The Illuminerdy (50% chance of SILVER)

Best Cartography (100%; I based this prediction purely on fanbase level, so I got both of these right.)

  • Pathfinder Campaign Setting: Wrath of the Righteous Poster Map Folio -Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (SILVER)

Best Electronic Book (50%; I’d hoped to have a chance of a Silver award for Corporia, but no luck this year. I find it interesting that I picked one Savage Worlds product for the Silver, but the other Savage Words product that actually won the Silver lists “Savage Worlds” in the nomination listing. Maybe Broken Earth just has more fans – I’ve certainly heard good things about it – but I do wonder how much it helped them to have “Savage Worlds” visible to the voters, whereas Shaintar did not.

  • Player’s Guide to Emerald City – Green Ronin Publishing (GOLD)
  • Broken Earth (Savage Worlds) – Sneak Attack Press (SILVER)

My predictions were:
Player’s Guide to Emerald City – Green Ronin Publishing (GOLD)
Shaintar: Legends Unleashed – Evil Beagle Games (SILVER)

Best Family Game (I was right when I said that Fate “fans might easily push it to Silver or Gold”.)

  • Fate Accelerated Edition – Evil Hat Productions (GOLD)
  • Hobbit Tales from the Green Dragon Inn – Cubicle 7 Entertainment (SILVER)

My official guesses were:
Hobbit Tales from the Green Dragon Inn – Cubicle 7 Entertainment (GOLD)
Little Wizards – Crafty Games (SILVER)

Best Free Product (I got these backwards, once again forgetting the Paizo fanbase numbers.)

  • Pathfinder Module: We Be Goblins Too! – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • Call of Cthulhu 7th Edition Quickstart – Chaosium Inc. (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
Call of Cthulhu 7th Edition Quickstart – Chaosium Inc. (GOLD)
Pathfinder Module: We Be Goblins Too! – Paizo Publishing (SILVER)

Best Game (I got these backwards, too.)

  • Fate Core System – Evil Hat Productions (GOLD)
  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
Fate Core System – Evil Hat Productions (SILVER)

Best Miniatures Product (50% here. Hmmm. Yet another one where the Pathfinder fanbase really prevailed.)

  • Pathfinder Battles: Wrath of the Righteous – WizKids Games/NECA (GOLD)
  • Pathfinder Battles: Wrath of the Righteous Gargantuan Demon Lord Deskari – WizKids Games/NECA (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
Pathfinder Battles: Wrath of the Righteous – WizKids Games/NECA (GOLD)
BattleTech: Alpha Strike – Catalyst Game Labs (SILVER)

Best Monster/Adversary (Two more I got backwards.)

  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Bestiary 4 – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • The Ninth World Bestiary – Monte Cook, LLC (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
The Ninth World Bestiary – Monte Cook, LLC (GOLD)
Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Bestiary 4 – Paizo Publishing (SILVER)

Best Podcast (I did say “I can also see my Gold and Silver guesses getting swapped”. I should have put Ken and Robin first, since I suspect their listener numbers are quite a bit higher than AGC (which I recently started listening to). Once again, I should also have just assumed that anything Numenera would win an award.)

  • Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff (GOLD)
  • Numenera: The Signal (SILVER)

I’d predicted the following:
All Games Considered (GOLD)
Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff (SILVER)

Best Production Values (50% here)

  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
  • Trail of Cthulhu: Eternal Lies – Pelgrane Press (SILVER)

I’d predicted the following:
Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
Iron Kingdoms Full Metal Fantasy RPG: Kings, Nations, and Gods – Privateer Press (SILVER)

Best RPG Related Product (100% – I guessed both of these)

  • Pathfinder Adventure Card Game: Rise of the Runelords Base Set – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
  • Strange Tales of the Century – Evil Hat Productions (SILVER)

Best Rules (100% of what I guessed. As I said originally, “Fate probably has this one wrapped up, just by being Fate. I didn’t pick a probable Silver since I can see it going anywhere in this category.”)

  • Fate Core System – Evil Hat Productions (GOLD)
  • 13th Age – Pelgrane Press (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
Fate Core System – Evil Hat Productions (GOLD)

Best Setting (I’d said “I wonder if there are enough Noir fans to push it into Silver.” It seems there were!)

  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
  • Deadlands Noir – Pinnacle Entertainment Group SILVER)

I had picked:
Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
Razor Coast – Frog God Games (SILVER)

Best Supplement (100% correct, even though I said “I haven’t used any of these supplements, so it’s another wild guess using what I know of the fanbases.”)

  • Pathfinder Roleplaying Game: Ultimate Campaign – Paizo Publishing (GOLD)
    Fate System Toolkit – Evil Hat Productions (SILVER)

Best Software (100% correct here too, but it was just wild guessing based on how much I see the product names mentioned around the web.)

  • Roll20 – The Orr Group LLC (GOLD)
  • Realm Works – Lone Wolf Development (SILVER)

Best Writing (I was right when I said “Here’s another where I can see my guesses for Silver and Gold being swapped in the final results.”)

  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
  • Achtung! Cthulhu – Keeper’s Guide to the Secret War – Modiphius (SILVER)

My predictions were:
Achtung! Cthulhu – Keeper’s Guide to the Secret War – Modiphius (GOLD)
Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (SILVER)

Best Website (These were wild guesses. Based on previous years I assumed the Escapist would win again, but I hadn’t reckoned with the Fate fanbase. Based on the other categories, I’m kind of surprised Fate didn’t get the Gold here.)

  • RPG Geek (GOLD)
  • Fate SRD (SILVER)

I’d predicted:
RPG Geek (GOLD)
The Escapist (SILVER)

Product of the Year (100%; I predicted both of these correctly.)

  • Numenera Corebook – Monte Cook Games, LLC (GOLD)
  • Fate Core System – Evil Hat Productions (SILVER)
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s